Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland: 9 Critical FOI Findings Before 1 November | JustMental
The Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland implementation
From tomorrow, Sunday 1 November 2026, the Police Service of Northern Ireland will no longer attend concern-for-welfare calls unless there is a risk to life, risk of harm, or a crime involved. The Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland model, in operation across parts of England and Wales since 2023, goes live here from tomorrow.
Sector voices in BBC News NI’s 30 October coverage
Over the past 24 hours, BBC News NI’s coverage of 30 October 2026 has carried significant sector voices on the implementation. Dr Ross Irvine of the Royal College of Psychiatrists in Northern Ireland warned that “a policy which removes the safety net that the PSNI are currently providing, and transfers that onto services that are already struggling to stand still, does give us cause for concern.” George Hannah of the British Association of Social Workers NI said “what we’re hearing from our members is this is too quick, there aren’t sufficient resources in the system to do it safely at the moment.” Prof Siobhán O’Neill, Mental Health Champion for Northern Ireland, said “I’m disappointed that there hasn’t been the investment in the health services and mental health services to ensure that there’s a backfill, alternative service.”
The 107 a Day campaign that JustMental launched on 30 June 2026 has, since July, pursued the same question through formal Freedom of Information requests. Nine substantive FOI responses have been received to date from the Department of Health, PSNI, and four of the five Health and Social Care Trusts. One further Trust response (South Eastern) is on a statutory response clock, due 20 November 2026. One Departmental internal review is overdue and now eligible for Information Commissioner’s Office escalation.
This article sets out, in one place, what those nine responses tell us on the eve of Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland implementation.
Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland is a defensible model in principle. On the public record of nine Freedom of Information responses received over the past three months, the receiving health service infrastructure, the operational baseline documentation, and the measurement framework for the handover have not been publicly confirmed as in place.
What the Department of Health has told us, and has refused to tell us
JustMental’s Freedom of Information response DOH 2026-0189, received 26 August 2026 in connection with the Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland campaign, confirmed that routine publication of CAMHS waiting time statistics in Northern Ireland had been suspended since May 2025, a 15-month gap at the time of the response. The Department stated in writing that “there are no other mental health waiting time statistics publications to resume.” The specific question about the operational baseline for Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland implementation was declined, with the response referring JustMental to a July 2023 Ernst & Young workforce review that pre-dates the operational rollout by over two years. The full analysis is at JustMental’s August analysis of the Department of Health FOI response. A formal internal review of that fifth response was lodged on 28 August 2026. The 20-working-day expected turnaround expired on 25 September 2026. The 40-working-day statutory outside limit expired on 23 October 2026. No internal review response has been received.
On 8 October 2026, the Department resumed publication of CAMHS waiting time statistics, the first such publication in 17 months. The data confirms 1,731 children were waiting for a CAMHS assessment in Northern Ireland as of 30 June 2026, of which 651 (38%) had been waiting more than nine weeks. Belfast HSC Trust alone accounts for 917 of those children. JustMental welcomed the resumption of publication publicly on 10 October.
A second DoH response, DOH 2026-0239 received 30 September 2026, provided Trust-by-Trust ED attendance figures for children’s mental health. Belfast HSC Trust returned a nil response because, in the Department’s own words, “reasons for attendance are not consistently recorded or clinically coded within Emergency Departments.” The Department also confirmed that it has not commissioned any trend analysis of Northern Ireland’s own data comparable to the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health’s analysis of NHS England data published on 2 September 2026.
What PSNI has told us, and what it has told us it does not know
JustMental’s FOI reference FOI/18565, received 18 September 2026, confirmed that PSNI holds no information on the volume of calls currently diverted to health service responders under the Right Care Right Person. Northern Ireland model.
The response issued a Section 12 cost-limit refusal on the full request, with a Section 16 offer of refinement on three of the five original questions.
A refined request, FOI/18693, received 16 October 2026, was refused under Section 12(4) of the Act, the aggregation clause that allows a public authority to combine the costs of multiple requests from the same person “acting in pursuance of a campaign.” The response did however disclose that PSNI’s District Policing Command G-drive alone holds 564 items relating to Right Care Right Person, with approximately 1,440 further emails estimated across a six-month window and at least 15 officers directly involved. The response also redirected the correspondence question to the Department of Health as a more direct route.
When JustMental asked PSNI how many concern-for-safety calls had been diverted to health service responders under Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland, PSNI confirmed in writing that no such information is held. When JustMental asked the Department of Health for the operational baseline against which safe implementation would be measured, the Department declined to disclose it. Neither institution has publicly answered the question of how the implementation beginning Sunday is being measured.
What four of the five HSC Trusts have told us
Four of the five Health and Social Care Trusts have responded substantively to parallel FOI requests on children’s mental health Emergency Department attendances between 2019/20 and 2025/26, in direct connection with the Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland implementation question.
Northern HSC Trust (FOI 4530, received 23 September 2026) provided a seven-year dataset covering 2,939 attendances, showing self-harm and suicidal presentations rising as a share of total attendances from approximately 9% in 2019/20 to approximately 37% in 2025/26 year-to-date. The Trust confirmed it holds no data cross-referencing children attending ED in mental health crisis with their concurrent CAMHS waiting list status.
Western HSC Trust (FOI26/4712, received 5 October 2026) provided a seven-year dataset covering 1,314 attendances across 29 presenting-reason categories, with coding caveats affecting direct year-on-year comparisons. The Trust confirmed under Section 12 that it holds no accessible CAMHS cross-reference data.
Southern HSC Trust (FOI 4002, received 9 October 2026) provided a methodologically transparent dataset split across the Business Objects extraction (pre-7 May 2025) and the EPIC extraction (post-7 May 2025), totalling 1,839 attendances. Just 21% of children attending Southern Trust EDs with mental health concerns under the new system have been seen within the four-hour standard. The Trust confirmed in writing that children arriving in mental health crisis at the Emergency Department outside the 9am-to-5pm Crisis Assessment and Intervention Team service hours wait until the next day for CAMHS assessment.
Belfast HSC Trust (FOI 38213, received 20 October 2026) provided a seven-year dataset totalling 2,566 attendances with an eight-category presenting-reason breakdown, notably contradicting the position previously communicated to the Department of Health. Suicidal thoughts/behaviour presentations rose from 58 in 2019/20 to 108 in 2025/26. Twenty-three children at Belfast Trust Emergency Departments waited more than 24 hours in 2025/26.
Â
The Trust confirmed that the data provided relates only to children referred by Emergency Department to the Crisis Assessment and Intervention Team, and that no timeframe exists for the consistent recording and coding of reasons for attendance. The Trust also confirmed that no data cross-referencing ED mental health attendances with CAMHS waiting list status is held.
South Eastern HSC Trust is the final Trust response outstanding. The request was re-opened on 23 October 2026 following a procedural scope clarification. Response expected 20 November 2026.
Four Trusts, in writing, in JustMental’s hands: no cross-referencing data between children attending Emergency Departments in mental health crisis and their concurrent CAMHS waiting list status is held in any form that permits reporting. Northern Ireland cannot, as of today, operationally link the moment of crisis in an Emergency Department with the queue the same child may already be in.
The four unanswered questions before implementation
The campaign’s position on Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland has not changed, and remains consistent with the 6 October statement. It is a defensible model in principle. Policing is not the appropriate response to a person in acute mental distress. The transfer of operational responsibility from policing to health is correct in direction.
The question is readiness, and the evidence base on Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland is now substantial. Four specific operational questions remain unanswered on the eve of implementation:
- The operational baseline for Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland implementation, refused by the Department of Health under FOI DOH 2026-0189, subject to an overdue internal review.
- The measurement framework for monitoring call diversion volumes, confirmed by PSNI as not currently held in a reportable form under FOI/18565.
- The system for cross-referencing children attending ED in crisis with their CAMHS waiting list status, confirmed by four separate HSC Trusts as not held in any accessible form.
- The out-of-hours receiving health service capacity for crisis presentations, confirmed by Southern HSC Trust under FOI 4002 as a 9-to-5 service, with out-of-hours ED crisis presentations waiting until the next day for CAMHS assessment.
Between tomorrow and the response of the final Trust FOI on 20 November 2026, JustMental will continue to report on the operational reality of Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland implementation. The next analysis will follow when the Department of Health publishes the first post-implementation operational data, or when the Information Commissioner’s Office processes the campaign’s complaint against the DoH’s failure to meet the internal review statutory response window, whichever comes first.
The campaign echoes the sector concerns voiced in BBC News NI’s coverage of 30 October 2026. It thanks the Royal College of Psychiatrists in Northern Ireland, the British Association of Social Workers NI, the Mental Health Champion’s office, PIPS Charity, and the Northern Ireland Commissioner for Children and Young People for their continuing public engagement with these questions.
Right Care Right Person Northern Ireland is the right model. On the public record of what the responsible institutions have been willing to disclose, Northern Ireland is proceeding to implementation with substantial questions on operational readiness still unanswered.
Spokesperson:
Karl Bennett, Co-Founder, JustMental
info@justmental.net | justmental.net
This is not wellness. This is war against stigma.
Crisis support
If reading this has been difficult, or if you or someone you know needs to talk, please reach out. Support is available.
Lifeline (Northern Ireland) · 0808 808 8000 · freephone, 24/7 · lifelinehelpline.info
Samaritans · 116 123 · freephone, 24/7 · samaritans.org
Childline · 0800 1111 · free, for children and young people · childline.org.uk
This is not wellness. This is war against stigma.


