Graphic on a near-black background reading ‘Suicide decriminalisation: what the law never said’, with the dates 1961, 1966 and 1993 and the JustMental name.

Suicide Decriminalisation: What the Law Never Said 

Suicide decriminalisation reached England and Wales in 1961, Northern Ireland in 1966 and the Republic of Ireland in 1993. Read the provisions that did it and you will notice something missing: they say nothing about the people who had already died.

At JustMental we think that is worth pausing on, so we have started looking into it. This is an early update on what we have found, what we have not, and where we are heading.

Suicide decriminalisation across the UK and Ireland: the dates

Three pieces of legislation ended the crime of suicide in different parts of these islands:

  • England and Wales: the Suicide Act 1961 (Royal Assent 3 August 1961). Section 1 reads: “The rule of law whereby it is a crime for a person to commit suicide is hereby abrogated.”
  • Northern Ireland: section 12 of the Criminal Justice Act (Northern Ireland) 1966 (Royal Assent 7 July 1966): “it shall no longer be an offence for a person to commit suicide.”
  • Republic of Ireland: section 2(1) of the Criminal Law (Suicide) Act 1993: “Suicide shall cease to be a crime.”

Scotland has its own legal history. We are still checking it, so we are making no claims about it here.

What the laws did not say

In the texts we have read, none of the laws behind suicide decriminalisation mentions people who died by suicide before the law changed. There is no pardon, no exoneration and no acknowledgement. Each is written in the present tense: from now on, this is no longer an offence.

That is not a criticism of those who passed the laws. It is an observation, and a question. Did anything formal ever follow, anywhere, to recognise the people who died, or the families left behind, under a law that treated their loss as a crime? We have not found it yet.

A pardon normally cancels a conviction, so whether one fits here is exactly the kind of question we need proper legal advice on. An acknowledgement or an apology may be the better ask. We have not decided, and we will not pretend to know before we do.

The people the law reached while they were alive

Suicide decriminalisation was not only about the dead. Attempted suicide was also treated as a crime. A written answer in the House of Commons on 13 February 1958 recorded 2,922 people convicted of attempted suicide in England and Wales between 1952 and 1956. Most were placed on probation or discharged, but 194 were sent to prison.

We are now looking for the equivalent records for Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. How families lived with the law is a harder question, and we will not guess at it. If it is part of your family’s story, there is a way to be in touch at the end of this article, whenever you are ready.

The word that outlived the law

Suicide decriminalisation changed the statute books. The language was slower to follow. The 1961 and 1966 Acts themselves use the word “commit”, and it stayed in everyday speech and headlines for decades. In 2018, an open letter compiled by Luciana Berger MP and Bryony Gordon, backed by Samaritans and Mind, called for the phrase to be dropped. Guidance from the NSPCC and from language guides that credit Samaritans now suggests “died by suicide”, because “commit” echoes a time when suicide was a crime.

That work deserves credit, and ours is a different question. It was about words. We are asking whether suicide decriminalisation should have come with anything more being said.

What JustMental is doing next

Our research into suicide decriminalisation is just starting. Over the coming weeks we will compare the original wording of each Act with the current versions, request official records on historic prosecutions, and seek legal advice, as well as advice from people who support those bereaved by suicide. We will report what we find on the JustMental blog, including anything that turns out to be wrong.

In our searching so far, we have not found an existing campaign asking for an acknowledgement or apology over the historic criminalisation of suicide in the UK or Ireland. We may well have missed one. If you know of one, please tell us. We would rather support good work than duplicate it.

If this is part of your family’s story, you do not need to share anything now. If you would like to be kept informed, or contacted when we have a safe, properly supported way to listen, email info@justmental.net. We will never publish anyone’s story without their clear consent.

If you need support

If you are struggling, or this article brings up difficult feelings, you do not have to cope alone. In Northern Ireland, Lifeline is free on 0808 808 8000, 24 hours a day. Samaritans is free on 116 123 across the UK and Ireland, day or night. In an emergency, call 999 (UK) or 999 or 112 (Ireland).